Once again, an overwhelming number of seats are not even seriously in play this year. This time going into election day 82 of 100 seats are considered "safe" for the party that currently controls them. Showing how much Democrats won the candidate recruitment war this year, these 82 seats do not look like the House as a whole, with 43 Republicans, 38 Democrats and 1 Independent.
However, as much as the House looks "in play" from those numbers, there are 8 more races that while not considered "safe" are considered "likely" wins for the incumbent party. These are races that could have been competitive but never quite got there. This list includes Watkins Abbitt, Chuck Caputo, Anne Crockett-Stark, Jeff Frederick, Tim Hugo, Robert Hurt's open seat, Scott Lingamfelter and Bob Marshall. With the likely's figured in the House goes to 49 Republicans, 39 Democrats and
2 Independents, both of whom will join with the GOP in reorganization. That will give Republicans another two years in the majority, but what will their margin be? Here are the 10 key races that will determine that:
9th House District- Eric Ferguson vs. Hon. Charles Poindexter
Bush/Kilgore/Bolling/McDonnell/Allen/Yes District
Outlook: Toss Up
In 2005, Eric started out as the huge underdog, got no help from Richmond and surged at the end to a very close result. In 2007, Eric started out with a huge lead and as Richmond Democrats have gotten involved the race gets closer and closer. Lesson for anyone?
14th House District- Hon. Adam Tomer vs. Delegate Danny Marshall
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/Deeds/Allen/Yes District
Outlook: Toss Up
This race has closed because Adam outworked the incumbent Delegate. Is that enough to win? We'll see.
21st House District- Bobby Matheison vs. Delegate John Welch
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/McDonnell/Webb/Yes District
Outlook: Toss Up
Every cycle when an incumbent goes down, its easy to point to special circumstances that involved that incumbent and not others. This one has a bunch of those circumstances, and so by recent history is the most likely incumbent defeat.
33rd House District- Delegate Joe May vs. Hon. Marty Martinez
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/McDonnell/Allen/Yes District
Outlook: Leans Republican
Joe May might end up winning here by a large margin, but Loudoun politics is too insane to call anything before election day.
34th House District- Dave Hunt vs. Margi Vanderhye
Kerry/Kaine/Byrne/Deeds/Webb/No District
Outlook: Likely Democratic (Pickup)
Margi played it safe in the primary and almost lost it, but her general election campaign has been flawless. After the 2006 debacle with the Weed campaign, Stephen Davis deserves a lot of credit here for redeeming himself and putting this seat in the Democratic pickup column.
51st House District- Faisal Gill vs. Paul Nichols
Bush/Kaine/Byrne/Deeds/Webb/Yes District
Outlook: Slight-Lean Democratic (Pickup)
Nichols campaign has played it safe in the general election, and as an unknown name that has been a huge strategic error. Combine that with the weird politics in Prince William County right now, and his lead has been disappearing faster than hair products at the Moran house. I still thinks Nichols holds on, but why is he talking about immigration and not about terrorism?
68th House District- Del. Katherine Waddell vs. Hon. Manoli Loupassi
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/McDonnell/Allen/No District
Outlook: Slight-Lean Republican (Pickup)
Loupassi is the best GOP candidate for this seat, but it has been a strange year and Waddell is fighting hard for re-election. I give him the slight edge but this could be closer than people expect.
83rd House District- Joe Bouchard vs. Chris Stolle
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/McDonnell/Allen/Yes District
Outlook: Slight-Lean Republican
Bouchard has run a little bit better campaign here, but this district has a slight lean to Republicans and I don't see a lot of crossover here, seeming to give Stolle a small edge going into election day.
86th House District- Jay Donahue vs. Delegate Tom Rust
Kerry/Kaine/Byrne/Deeds/Webb/Yes District
Outlook: Leans Republican
This district is way too Democratic for a Republican to hold, but Rust has always been popular here. I think he will sneak by this year because of the immigration hot spots in this district in Herndon and Sterling. However, unless something changes here, Tom will be very vulnerable in 2009, downballot from a Governor's race. Rematch?
87th House District- Delegate Paula Miller vs. Hank Giffin
Bush/Kaine/Bolling/McDonnell/Webb/Yes District
Outlook: Leans Democratic
Miller has never impressed here with her showings and Giffin will come closer than he should because of this. Ironically the Senate candidate Paula was supposed to help, Ralph Northam, may have coattails that end up saving her. The big question now is- will Paula be able to hang on in 2009 if Bob McDonnell is leading the GOP ticket.
-------------------
If the close races break as I expect, there will be 53 Republicans, 42 Democrats, 2 Independents going into the three tossup seats. Not impressive for the GOP which tried to draw itself 66 safe seats a few years ago. Democrats are basically guaranteed a pickup this year, and the only question now is what size it is, and whether it is large enough to make a play at the majority in 2009.